Hotel operators disappointed weight of supporting the Y will fall on themPublished 10:55pm Friday, January 18, 2013
Selma city hotel owners and managers voiced their opposition to the proposed lodging fee at the Selma Administrative Committee meeting Friday.
The meeting, chaired by council president Corey Bowie, was held to give hotel owners a podium for their input on the proposed fee and to allow board members of the YMCA, Selma Mayor George Evans and council members a chance to offer their thoughts as well.
The proposed lodging fee — or occupancy fee — increase would go to help financially stabilize and support the YMCA of Selma.
“We have already drafted the ordinance to vote on so we can vote it up or down,” Bowie said of the additional lodging fee. “If we do implement the occupancy fee there are still some logistics we need to look at and work out, like we need to look at what the time period would be on this (one year, two years, three years,) and another dynamic we need to look at is the status of the YMCA.”
Bowie said he would ask to see a list of the programming the YMCA would be able to create and also look at re-engineering strategies the YMCA could use so that they would not end up in the same financial situation they are currently in.
YMCA volunteer board member, Ronnie Leet, put together a list of those programs that would come about, or strengthen, with the help of the occupancy fee increase.
On the list was childcare for children in a safe and stimulating environment; after school programs that focus on safety, health and academic enhancement; youth and government programs to teach children about civic duties and leadership training courses would all be offered. Leet also listed swimming lessons, community initiatives for health, social programs, youth sports like volleyball and basketball, recreation and adult sports.
“I know a lot of hotel owners in here have expressed a grave concern about the Brown YMCA and we are going to add 50 cents on to support the Brown YMCA for a total of $2,” Bowie said. “Then $1.50 would go towards the Walker-Johnson facility and 50 cents would go towards the YMCA.”
In a previous work session Evans announced to the council he believed it would take about $300,000 to bring the Brown YMCA up to shape and open it up again. However the concerns from the hotel owners and managers did not seem to stem from concern about helping the Brown YMCA in the committee meeting. Hotel workers expressed they felt the fee was simply unfair.
“I am a member of the YMCA, and my family has been members since it opened, so we want to support the YMCA,” said Dr. Freij Walid, owner of the Hampton Inn. “If you want to impose something in the community for the YMCA, we need to ask the whole community to contribute to that if you are going to ask businesses to support the YMCA ask all businesses to support it like restaurants, plumbers, lawyers, doctors, everyone … I have a problem with selecting a group or a subset of businesses.”
He said if the ordinance imposed that all businesses be taxed, he would be in favor of helping the YMCA in that regard, but felt it was unfair to ask the hotels to help and no other businesses. He also said if the ordinance passed, there would be no hard feelings between himself the YMCA and the council.
“The YMCA serves my kids, not someone who is visiting from Michigan for three days,” Walid said in regards to making tourists pay the fee.
Others, like Angela Hurst who manages the St. James Hotel, asked what the YMCA and city of Selma would do in turn for the hotels in getting more occupants into the hotels.
Leet said the YMCA is offering all hotel employees and their families free memberships to the YMCA and also giving hotel guests a free pass to the YMCA for each night of their stay.
“Secondly, we thought this was a way to not tax the citizens of Selma,” Leet said, “and give them any more burden of what they are being taxed, we felt that in comparing rates between Selma and five other surrounding cities that this per room, per night fee would not discourage anyone from staying in Selma by going to another city to stay because of this.”
Several hotel owners presented those at the committee meeting with their own numbers on what percentage of the rooms at their businesses stay occupied annually. The proposed fee increase is based on an estimation of generating $188,000 while numbers the hotel owners presented showed that less than $80,000 would be made.
The council will vote on the occupancy fee Tuesday. Following the vote if it were to pass, there would be another document in discussion, a contract for the ordinance between the city and the YMCA, which would need to be voted on at a later date.
Council members have to decide on the amount of time or the “sunset provision” for the ordinance. This means the time allotted for the ordinance before it is reviewed and possibly renewed.